Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Executing the act of curiosity


Following my last blog, I came across a lot of content that shares how to create good interview questions. This TEDx stood out to me in particular as I feel it relates to qualitative research...




In this video, Dan Moulthrop shares some important tips and stories. He discusses that the way you ask a question is significant to the response you get. For example, instead of asking someone "what job do you do?", ask them "how do you feel about what you do?". 

"Asking a good question is about executing the act of curiosity."

When Moulthrop mentioned this, I remembered a blog I wrote back in module one about assumptions and curiosity. Although I could reflect on my previous experience to write a blog at the time, these ideas did not feel so apparent. Now I am going through the process of designing a research project, I am understanding this in more depth. My curiosity has led to me wanting to find out more about dance education, however, I am having to put aside my personal experiences and preconceptions to allow the development of new thoughts.

 Finally, he discusses the importance of being empathetic and grateful, which I think is a simple skill, but also incredibly powerful!


TEDx Talks, 2021. The Art Of Asking Questions | Dan Moulthrop | TEDxSHHS. [video] Available at: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZSY0PssqH0&t=421s> [Accessed 28 April 2021].

Monday, April 19, 2021

Interviewing - Zoom - 18.04.21




I was aware of the types of data collection methods that suit qualitative research (such as interviews, surveys, case studies, experimental, etc.) however, I initially found it difficult to choose methods that would best fit my research. For example, I was concerned that by observing dance teachers during class, the teacher would feel pressure and alter their teaching methods, meaning the data I collect wouldn't be authentic. I was also concerned that by engaging with participants face-to-face they wouldn't feel comfortable sharing information. Although I considered this carefully, I now realise there will be complications with every type of data collection method. How we interpret the data collected is equally as important. 

Sam led a Zoom session last week about interviews. I found it insightful and will definitely be using his tips when I begin collecting data next module. Some of the tips he shared were...

Even if you know the participants personally, you can never predict what they will say. Don't go into the interview with any fixed ideas. Have an open mind. 

The aim of interviews is to collect stories. This is actually the reason I chose to do interviews as a data collection method as I am interested to learn about the teaching methods that dance teachers have adopted and why. What do the dance teacher's stories tell me about dance education? I am excited to find out.

Start by asking a simple question (i.e. "How did you get into your field of practice?") to break the ice. Then, ensure you actively listen to the participants. This might be difficult (especially as first-time researchers) which is why it's important to use a dictaphone to record the interviews. Also, ensure to engage with the participants by showing interest; give eye contact, respond and pick up on key points. It is also important not to offer opposing views on topics, we can simply acknowledge their opinions and move on. 

I am excited to do interviews, but also quite scared. Although there is a lot to consider, it is also important to remember that we don't have to do everything. 5 main questions are enough. And by the time we get to it next module, we will be more prepared and it will feel more natural (I hope).

I have now received my feedback for my Proposal and am slightly overwhelmed with the notes I received. One note was to give a flavour to the type of questions I will ask in my interviews. Sam suggested looking at 'The Ethnographic Interview' by James Spradley but it's not available in the Online Library. If anyone has any tips on how to approach this, I would really appreciate it. 


References

Bhandari, P., 2021. Data Collection | A Step-by-Step Guide with Methods and Examples. [online] Scribbr. Available at: <https://www.scribbr.com/methodology/data-collection/> [Accessed 19 April 2021].

Granada Preparatory School, 2021. job-interview-clipart-243. [image] Available at: <https://chaschool.org/staff/pam-green/job-interview-clipart-243/> [Accessed 19 April 2021].

Spradley, J., 2021. The Ethnographic Interview.

Wednesday, March 24, 2021

MORE form discussion session - 23.03.21

The Middlesex Online Research Ethics form has been lingering in my brain for a while now. On Tuesday, we were fortunate enough to have an additional session where Helen walked us through the MORE form, and I found it extremely helpful. So many useful points were made, but the following were most significant to me...

  • It is okay to use short sentences and bullet point answers. Before this I was attempting to answer my questions in an essay format so that I could copy and paste it into my inquiry proposal.
  • It is okay to not provide a lengthy answer every question - if the question asks if you anticipate any negative impacts, if suitable, the answer may be 'I don't anticipate any'. 
  • If interviews are being used, they need to be in a public place and a debrief must be incorporated.
  • Participants should have the right to give no comment and/or have the interview terminated at any point. They also have the right to decide if they no longer wish to be part of the study even after their interview. However, this decision must be made within six weeks so an arrangement can be done to find another participant. 
Before, I wasn't confident or satisfied by the answers I was providing, however, I now feel that it is not so daunting. I am excited to open up my MORE form again with a different perspective.


Sunday, March 21, 2021

Just a little reflection


Can anyone else relate?

Since schools went back after lockdown, I have found it challenging to balance work and study. I am now utilising any spare time I have to work on my Literature Review, MORE form and Inquiry Proposal. It is safe to say blogging has been the last thing on my agenda, so I thought it was about time to do a little catch-up blog...

Writing my literature review really helped me pin-point an inquiry title. I began by reading literature around the topic of teacher/student relationships in dance education. Many themes popped up such as self-esteem, authoritarianism, power balance (or imbalance), care, dialogue and the role of the student. However, these themes did not initially help with my aim to find an inquiry title. I had to map these themes and discover what I really wanted to find out from my research. This led me to realise that I actually wanted to know which aspects of the teacher/student relationship best support the student's learning experience. I am excited to see what my research unveils next module.

I have been working through the MORE form and proposal together and admittedly have found it really difficult. I began Module Two by reading all about what is meant by a qualitative non-positivist approach to research and felt fairly confident that I knew what I was going to do. However, whilst writing about methodology and data collection methods in both my Literature Review and Proposal, I realised I was unsure which approach would be most valuable to my research. There was a lot more to consider; what would make the participants feel more comfortable in sharing, how I could best support them and what am I really wanting to get from my data collection, as well as considering the 12 weeks time frame. I have been looking further into ethnography and narrative research to discover which approach would best suit my inquiry. Although I have a rough idea, I am hoping to discuss this further in my mid-term supervision this week.

Although I am facing these challenges now, I can't help but think that at least I will have something to write about in my Reflective Essay... 

I hope you are all well :) 

Thursday, March 4, 2021

Educating the creative heart

Thank you to everyone who read my last post and shared their stories! It has really encouraged my thoughts to progress...

I had a very interesting supervision with Sam yesterday. It was lovely to express my ideas and have some new ideas fed back. Although I have not yet decided on my inquiry title, I have chosen to go with the theme of 'student/teacher relationship in dance'. I find this theme fascinating and feel that this idea would be most beneficial for my future practice.

As an SEN teaching assistant, I recognise that by building positive relationships with students is extremely important to their learning and development. But when I reflect this on education in dance, it's like entering a completely different world. I now question whether dancers would have a better chance of success if they had better relationships with their teachers.

I also came across an inspiring (yet comical) TED Talk entitled 'Every kid needs a champion'. Rita Pierson (a professional educator) discusses how every student deserves a teacher who understands the power of connection and insists that their students become the best the can possibly be. 

What I am noticing during my research so far is there is some great literature that discusses the importance of a teacher/student relationships, but not so much in dance education, especially in the most recent years. 

To be an artist is extremely challenging, and it can be particularly difficult for students with big ambitions who are uncertain about the future. It can be even harder if they don't feel supported by their educators. (Buckroyd, 2000)

So, what do I think makes a good dance teacher?

I already know that to be a good teacher you need to be organised, trustworthy, creative, patient and knowledgable. But is an emotional connection as important to students studying dance?

I once had a dance teacher who I will never forget. I shall name them X for the purpose of this blog...

X always had time to talk to students about issues out of class whether it was personal or about dance. X gave feedback in a positive way and their use of dialogue was professional, fair and reassuring. X wasn't intimidating, but strict enough to get the best out of students. X was passionate about dance, and this was obvious in all lessons. All students wanted to respect X because X always showed respect to students. In my eyes, X had all the qualities of good teacher physically and emotionally.

I am concerned that I am using my own assumptions to help me find an inquiry topic, therefore I would be very interested to know what you think makes a good teacher, whether that be in dance, musical theatre, acting or music? 




References

Ballet Papier.  2021. [image] Available at: <https://www.balletpapier.com/about-us-and-what-we-do> [Accessed 4 March 2021].

Buckroyd, J., 2000. The student dancer.  Cecil Court London: Dance Books

TED, 2021. [video] Available at: <https://www.ted.com/talks/rita_pierson_every_kid_needs_a_champion?language=en#t-430329> [Accessed 4 March 2021].


Monday, February 22, 2021

The power of a book

I have enjoyed reading everyone's reflections on the Zoom sessions that took place last week, but would it be completely out of the ordinary for me to say I felt more confused. Everyone seemed so confident and in tune with their opinions (which was inspiring) but for me, I felt lost in my own thoughts.

So I read a book. An actual book that had arrived in the post from the Middlesex Library. As someone who is not much of a reader, I became completely engrossed by this book and finished it in three days. I was amazed that after only the reading the first chapter, I had already made a mind map of all my new ideas. Two topics have particularly resonated with me, and I would love to share them and hear what you all have to say...

  • Feelings and emotions of the dancer, and how they can effect the dancer's movement and ability to perform
When I was studying dance, a reoccurring correction of mine was to forget about the technique and perform more. There was something blocking my learning, and when I reflect back, I recognise it was phycological. I was so anxious... Was my technique good enough? Was I ever going to be good enough and achieve a successful career? It wasn't easy to overcome, but I am grateful for the journey I took as I learnt a lot about myself. I now question how much do negative emotions effect the dancer's ability to perform, in both educational and professional settings. Some dancers can use their emotions to cultivate movement, but others need a free headspace. But what is the difference between these two types of dancers?

  • The relationship between a dancer and a teacher, and how collaboration can allow for the dancer to fully flourish
I think all dancers, singers, actors can think back to a time where a teacher or choreographer has given a piece of criticism that made you feel crap. Or received criticism in front of a whole class and made you feel embarrassed. Does this type of feedback help dancers improve? For some, this can give them the motivation to work harder, but for others, it can make them feel incapable, possibly causing mental health issues, eating disorders or even tempting them to quit dance altogether. Can corrections be given in a way that encourages students rather than the opposite? Can a healthy relationship between the dancer and student help student's gain more from their education? And what is needed for this 'collaboration' happen?


I have so many questions brewing now, but I know that I am not looking to solve anything yet. However, I think it's important to have an idea of what makes me 'wonder' so I can discover what it I want to investigate further.

The book I read is called 'The Student Dancer' (Buckroyd, n.d.) and it covers many different emotional and phycological aspects of learning dance at a professional level. If anyone has any questions about it or wonders whether it could help them with their research, I would be happy to help x

References

Buckroyd, J., n.d. The Student Dancer.

deMilked,  2021. [image]  Available at: <https://www.demilked.com/book-installation-the-castle-jorge-mendez-blake/> [Accessed 21 February 2021].

Wednesday, February 17, 2021

Off on a tangent... Qualitative Research

The idea of 'researching research' seemed bizarre to me at first because I just wanted to start researching ideas around my inquiry topic. But I went with it and I am glad I did. I began reading the Kortext book 'Qualitative Research for Physical Culture' (Markula and Silk, 2011). I would especially recommend chapter three to anyone who hasn't had a look yet. It discusses how to structure a qualitative research project, as well as some very useful tips on producing a successful Literature Review.

I was interested to learn about the process of qualitative research in comparison to quantitive. Quantitive research is the process of collecting and analysing numerical data (Base and research, 2021) and is known to follow a rigid order as shown below...

 (Markula and Silk, 2011, p. 58)

Qualitative research is more flexible and is what we will be using on this course. Although the process still needs order, it is possible to complete certain stages simultaneously. Additionally, certain parts of the research will continually be shaped throughout the process. An example of this is shown below...

 (Markula and Silk, 2011, p. 59)

For anyone who knows me well will know how much I loved planning and organising. This morning when I woke up, I made a plan of exactly what I wanted to achieve today from exercise, study and even planning time for myself (I am a bit of a Monica Gellar). I will need to learn to embrace uncertainty and 'go with the flow' this module.

A certain key word kept popping up during my reading - meaningful. This means that the purpose of the research must be valued by the researcher. The researcher will also have to reflect on the differences between the researcher and the participants, as well as be self-reflexive throughout the entire process. 

"As humans we often defend an idea by giving reasons for it. However, sometimes the best defense is not to give reasons at the outset but instead to pursue the idea in order to see where it leads." (iDoGrants, 2019)

I would love to ask you all now, how do you know when to stop researching research and start researching different ideas, but that would contradict what I have just learnt about 'flexibility in qualitative research'. So I am now going to start researching around my inquiry topic, but come back to literature around qualitative research whenever I feel it is necessary. 

I feel like I have gone off on a bit of a tangent whilst writing this post, but I think I can synthesise everything by reflecting on the TEDtalk that was shared by Alys and Helen at the beginning of the week - 'The power of vulnerability'. In the video, Brené Brown shares how she learnt to embrace vulnerability in order to get the most out of life. When I first watched it on Monday, I was feeling lost and frustrated about my study and where I was going with Module Two but it instantly helped me realise that it is okay if things don't go the way I hope. It also helped me recognise that if I do my research with love, courage and meaning then I will hopefully be able to get the most out of it...

I think this is what qualitative research is all about. What do you think?



References

Base, K. and research, A., 2021. What Is Quantitative Research? | Definition, Uses and Methods. [online] Scribbr. Available at: <https://www.scribbr.com/methodology/quantitative-research/#:~:text=Quantitative%20research%20is%20the%20process,generalize%20results%20to%20wider%20populations.> [Accessed 17 February 2021].

iDoGrants, V., 2021. Meaningful research must feel meaningful and be worthwhile; both valued and valuable.. [online] I Do Grants.org. Available at: <https://idogrants.org/2019/05/05/meaningful-research-must-feel-meaningful-and-be-worthwhile-both-valued-and-valuable/> [Accessed 17 February 2021].

Markula, P. and Silk, M., 2011. Qualitative research for physical culture. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.

TEDxHouston, 2021. The power of vulnerability. [video] Available at: <https://www.ted.com/talks/brene_brown_the_power_of_vulnerability?language=en#t-529652> [Accessed 17 February 2021].

Celebrating Submission!

Wow, what a module! Congratulations to everyone who has submitted their work already! I have just submitted my portfolio and am feeling amaz...