Saturday, September 18, 2021

All things... questions!

Wow... Week 1 has gone so fast. I have spent my time refamiliarising myself with literature that I found particularly helpful in module 2, recruiting participants, exploring interview questions, and studying interview techniques. 

I will be using a combination of interviews and questionnaires to collect data for my inquiry. I am really excited to see how data differs depending on the way questions are asked (verbally or digitally).

As interviews are so foreign to me, I thought it would be good to do some research about how to interview. I began thinking about this in module 2 and came across a TedX by Dan Moulthrop entitled 'The Art Of Asking Questions' (I shared it in a blog, which you can see here). Moulthrop shares some great tips about choosing questions and different interview approaches. These are his 8 key points:

  1. Be unafraid
  2. Be curious
  3. Try the obvious questions
  4. The words you use matter
  5. Strive for empathy 
  6. Be informed
  7. Be simple 
  8. Be gracious
He made it seem so simple. I was still unsure so read/listened to some published interviews. Sam recommended 'The Ethnographic Interview', which reminds readers that interviews are very similar to the friendly conversation, and funnily enough, if you Youtube interviews, many are entitled 'A conversation with...'. I then listened to an interview of Billy Joel (which took place in 1963). He was being interviewed by Studs Terkel, a very famous author/broadcaster. He interviewed with such ease. Although he already had knowledge of Joel's background, he asked simple questions, showed a lot of interest, and responded effectively and graciously. I thought it particularly impressive when Terkel would pick up on small fragments of Joel's answers and ask him to expand on this. I thought it was quite beautiful actually.

I had a super helpful tutorial with Sam yesterday. We discussed my interview questions and my approach to interviews. He reinforced the idea of simple interview questions and reminded me that I must be prepared in case participants ask for questions reworded.

For now, I have stopped worrying about interviews, and have composed some interview questions that I have put a lot of thought into. I will also be modifying these questions to suit my questionnaires better. I am excited to see where this leads me and will hoping be documenting my progress/findings soon.


References

Spradley, J., n.d. The ethnographic interview.

TEDx Talks, 2021. The Art Of Asking Questions | Dan Moulthrop | TEDxSHHS. [video] Available at: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZSY0PssqH0&t=421s> [Accessed 28 April 2021].

2021. Bob Dylan interviewed by Studs Terkel (1963). [video] Available at: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYdvOPRE3EQ&t=172s> [Accessed 18 September 2021].

Monday, September 13, 2021

New beginnings all round

I can't believe how quickly the time has gone since we were last here. I hope everyone had an excellent break!

This summer, I spent time with some friends and family who I hadn't seen since pre-covid. I also relocated to the seaside, something I have wanted to do for a very long time.

A new home comes with a fresh start, and a new job, and I was so happy to find a job that was similar to my previous one as a teaching assistant, only this one is within an independent school. I was really excited about this job as the headteacher is highly enthusiastic about the arts. His focus is on music, and he is a strong believer that the arts play an important role in a child's development. I am so excited for this next year to learn more about arts and education, to work in collaboration with others, and to hopefully develop myself and my practice.

I spent some time last week becoming familiar with module 3, reading the handbook, and reviewing my inquiry project, but I have been putting off writing a blog as I am still feeling a bit apprehensive about this module. I suppose there is always a fear of the unknown, and undergoing an inquiry is so unfamiliar to me. So I have a new mantra…



The handbook really emphasises the importance of YOU during the inquiry process. I think it could be very easy to forget that the ultimate purpose is to develop ourselves. I chose my topic because I want to become more reflective as a practitioner, but my discoveries could be at risk if I don't value my role within the research. When I remind myself of this, it actually brings me peace of mind, knowing that within this very unfamiliar process of research is something very familiar.

"Begin to see your practice as your research, not separate to it."

Wishing everyone from all modules an amazing term :)


Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Executing the act of curiosity


Following my last blog, I came across a lot of content that shares how to create good interview questions. This TEDx stood out to me in particular as I feel it relates to qualitative research...




In this video, Dan Moulthrop shares some important tips and stories. He discusses that the way you ask a question is significant to the response you get. For example, instead of asking someone "what job do you do?", ask them "how do you feel about what you do?". 

"Asking a good question is about executing the act of curiosity."

When Moulthrop mentioned this, I remembered a blog I wrote back in module one about assumptions and curiosity. Although I could reflect on my previous experience to write a blog at the time, these ideas did not feel so apparent. Now I am going through the process of designing a research project, I am understanding this in more depth. My curiosity has led to me wanting to find out more about dance education, however, I am having to put aside my personal experiences and preconceptions to allow the development of new thoughts.

 Finally, he discusses the importance of being empathetic and grateful, which I think is a simple skill, but also incredibly powerful!


TEDx Talks, 2021. The Art Of Asking Questions | Dan Moulthrop | TEDxSHHS. [video] Available at: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZSY0PssqH0&t=421s> [Accessed 28 April 2021].

Monday, April 19, 2021

Interviewing - Zoom - 18.04.21




I was aware of the types of data collection methods that suit qualitative research (such as interviews, surveys, case studies, experimental, etc.) however, I initially found it difficult to choose methods that would best fit my research. For example, I was concerned that by observing dance teachers during class, the teacher would feel pressure and alter their teaching methods, meaning the data I collect wouldn't be authentic. I was also concerned that by engaging with participants face-to-face they wouldn't feel comfortable sharing information. Although I considered this carefully, I now realise there will be complications with every type of data collection method. How we interpret the data collected is equally as important. 

Sam led a Zoom session last week about interviews. I found it insightful and will definitely be using his tips when I begin collecting data next module. Some of the tips he shared were...

Even if you know the participants personally, you can never predict what they will say. Don't go into the interview with any fixed ideas. Have an open mind. 

The aim of interviews is to collect stories. This is actually the reason I chose to do interviews as a data collection method as I am interested to learn about the teaching methods that dance teachers have adopted and why. What do the dance teacher's stories tell me about dance education? I am excited to find out.

Start by asking a simple question (i.e. "How did you get into your field of practice?") to break the ice. Then, ensure you actively listen to the participants. This might be difficult (especially as first-time researchers) which is why it's important to use a dictaphone to record the interviews. Also, ensure to engage with the participants by showing interest; give eye contact, respond and pick up on key points. It is also important not to offer opposing views on topics, we can simply acknowledge their opinions and move on. 

I am excited to do interviews, but also quite scared. Although there is a lot to consider, it is also important to remember that we don't have to do everything. 5 main questions are enough. And by the time we get to it next module, we will be more prepared and it will feel more natural (I hope).

I have now received my feedback for my Proposal and am slightly overwhelmed with the notes I received. One note was to give a flavour to the type of questions I will ask in my interviews. Sam suggested looking at 'The Ethnographic Interview' by James Spradley but it's not available in the Online Library. If anyone has any tips on how to approach this, I would really appreciate it. 


References

Bhandari, P., 2021. Data Collection | A Step-by-Step Guide with Methods and Examples. [online] Scribbr. Available at: <https://www.scribbr.com/methodology/data-collection/> [Accessed 19 April 2021].

Granada Preparatory School, 2021. job-interview-clipart-243. [image] Available at: <https://chaschool.org/staff/pam-green/job-interview-clipart-243/> [Accessed 19 April 2021].

Spradley, J., 2021. The Ethnographic Interview.

Wednesday, March 24, 2021

MORE form discussion session - 23.03.21

The Middlesex Online Research Ethics form has been lingering in my brain for a while now. On Tuesday, we were fortunate enough to have an additional session where Helen walked us through the MORE form, and I found it extremely helpful. So many useful points were made, but the following were most significant to me...

  • It is okay to use short sentences and bullet point answers. Before this I was attempting to answer my questions in an essay format so that I could copy and paste it into my inquiry proposal.
  • It is okay to not provide a lengthy answer every question - if the question asks if you anticipate any negative impacts, if suitable, the answer may be 'I don't anticipate any'. 
  • If interviews are being used, they need to be in a public place and a debrief must be incorporated.
  • Participants should have the right to give no comment and/or have the interview terminated at any point. They also have the right to decide if they no longer wish to be part of the study even after their interview. However, this decision must be made within six weeks so an arrangement can be done to find another participant. 
Before, I wasn't confident or satisfied by the answers I was providing, however, I now feel that it is not so daunting. I am excited to open up my MORE form again with a different perspective.


Sunday, March 21, 2021

Just a little reflection


Can anyone else relate?

Since schools went back after lockdown, I have found it challenging to balance work and study. I am now utilising any spare time I have to work on my Literature Review, MORE form and Inquiry Proposal. It is safe to say blogging has been the last thing on my agenda, so I thought it was about time to do a little catch-up blog...

Writing my literature review really helped me pin-point an inquiry title. I began by reading literature around the topic of teacher/student relationships in dance education. Many themes popped up such as self-esteem, authoritarianism, power balance (or imbalance), care, dialogue and the role of the student. However, these themes did not initially help with my aim to find an inquiry title. I had to map these themes and discover what I really wanted to find out from my research. This led me to realise that I actually wanted to know which aspects of the teacher/student relationship best support the student's learning experience. I am excited to see what my research unveils next module.

I have been working through the MORE form and proposal together and admittedly have found it really difficult. I began Module Two by reading all about what is meant by a qualitative non-positivist approach to research and felt fairly confident that I knew what I was going to do. However, whilst writing about methodology and data collection methods in both my Literature Review and Proposal, I realised I was unsure which approach would be most valuable to my research. There was a lot more to consider; what would make the participants feel more comfortable in sharing, how I could best support them and what am I really wanting to get from my data collection, as well as considering the 12 weeks time frame. I have been looking further into ethnography and narrative research to discover which approach would best suit my inquiry. Although I have a rough idea, I am hoping to discuss this further in my mid-term supervision this week.

Although I am facing these challenges now, I can't help but think that at least I will have something to write about in my Reflective Essay... 

I hope you are all well :) 

Thursday, March 4, 2021

Educating the creative heart

Thank you to everyone who read my last post and shared their stories! It has really encouraged my thoughts to progress...

I had a very interesting supervision with Sam yesterday. It was lovely to express my ideas and have some new ideas fed back. Although I have not yet decided on my inquiry title, I have chosen to go with the theme of 'student/teacher relationship in dance'. I find this theme fascinating and feel that this idea would be most beneficial for my future practice.

As an SEN teaching assistant, I recognise that by building positive relationships with students is extremely important to their learning and development. But when I reflect this on education in dance, it's like entering a completely different world. I now question whether dancers would have a better chance of success if they had better relationships with their teachers.

I also came across an inspiring (yet comical) TED Talk entitled 'Every kid needs a champion'. Rita Pierson (a professional educator) discusses how every student deserves a teacher who understands the power of connection and insists that their students become the best the can possibly be. 

What I am noticing during my research so far is there is some great literature that discusses the importance of a teacher/student relationships, but not so much in dance education, especially in the most recent years. 

To be an artist is extremely challenging, and it can be particularly difficult for students with big ambitions who are uncertain about the future. It can be even harder if they don't feel supported by their educators. (Buckroyd, 2000)

So, what do I think makes a good dance teacher?

I already know that to be a good teacher you need to be organised, trustworthy, creative, patient and knowledgable. But is an emotional connection as important to students studying dance?

I once had a dance teacher who I will never forget. I shall name them X for the purpose of this blog...

X always had time to talk to students about issues out of class whether it was personal or about dance. X gave feedback in a positive way and their use of dialogue was professional, fair and reassuring. X wasn't intimidating, but strict enough to get the best out of students. X was passionate about dance, and this was obvious in all lessons. All students wanted to respect X because X always showed respect to students. In my eyes, X had all the qualities of good teacher physically and emotionally.

I am concerned that I am using my own assumptions to help me find an inquiry topic, therefore I would be very interested to know what you think makes a good teacher, whether that be in dance, musical theatre, acting or music? 




References

Ballet Papier.  2021. [image] Available at: <https://www.balletpapier.com/about-us-and-what-we-do> [Accessed 4 March 2021].

Buckroyd, J., 2000. The student dancer.  Cecil Court London: Dance Books

TED, 2021. [video] Available at: <https://www.ted.com/talks/rita_pierson_every_kid_needs_a_champion?language=en#t-430329> [Accessed 4 March 2021].


Celebrating Submission!

Wow, what a module! Congratulations to everyone who has submitted their work already! I have just submitted my portfolio and am feeling amaz...